Logos Consulting Deutsch

Solar power and the circular economy

In 2012 I carried out the factory acceptance of the first Plug & Save modules in Wenzhou, China, and today I am building a circular economy for used solar modules with GE4A. On this page I explain both: how solar power got onto the balcony, and why a decommissioned module is not automatically waste.

What is balcony solar (plug-in solar)?

A balcony solar system, called a plug-in solar device (Steckersolargerät) in German law, is a small photovoltaic system that feeds its electricity into the household circuit through an ordinary socket. The power is used in the home first, which directly reduces the amount drawn from the grid.

A system like this consists of one or more solar panels, an inverter that converts the direct current into grid-standard alternating current and, if wanted, a battery. It needs no roof of its own and no installer to connect it. This means tenants can generate their own solar power too.

How did balcony solar start in Europe?

Toralf Nitsch is one of the pioneers of balcony solar in Europe. In 2012 he carried out the factory acceptance of Sun Invention's first Plug & Save modules at the factory in Wenzhou, China: a plug-in solar panel with a built-in inverter and battery.

We officially launched Plug & Save in Kassel on 8 August 2012, and it became widely known through Frank Farenski's cinema documentary „Leben mit der Energiewende“. In December 2012 the US magazine Inhabitat described Plug & Save as the world's first mobile solar panel with built-in storage and inverter. In 2013 I was technical director and later COO of Sun Invention. Production started at ALGATEC Solar in Brandenburg, Germany, in May 2013, and in June we showed the product at Intersolar Europe in Munich.

It was not easy. In April 2013 the VDE, Germany's association for electrical engineering and standards, publicly warned against plug-in solar systems. My answer at the time was that the existing standards had never been made or intended for mini PV systems. I did not invent balcony solar. But I helped get the movement started in Europe. The full story of Plug & Save

What are the rules for balcony solar in Germany?

Since Germany's Solar Package I (Solarpaket I) came into force on 16 May 2024, plug-in solar devices with up to 800 VA of inverter output and 2,000 watts of panel capacity have enjoyed privileged legal status. They only need a simplified entry in the Marktstammdatenregister, Germany's official register of energy installations, and notifying the grid operator is no longer required.

Inverter
800 VA maximum; several devices are added together
Panels
2,000 watts maximum
Registration
simplified entry in the Marktstammdatenregister (since 1 April 2024); no notification to the grid operator (since May 2024)
Old meter
may temporarily run backwards until the grid operator installs a bidirectional meter
Tenants and owners
a privileged measure since October 2024; landlords and owners' associations may only refuse if it would be unreasonable for them
Product standard
DIN VDE V 0126-95 since December 2025 (pre-standard) for devices without a battery

The simplified registration does not yet apply to devices with a battery; the battery has to be registered with the grid operator. According to the Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur), the 800 VA limit refers to the highest output the inverter can be set to, not the output it is currently set to.

How many balcony solar systems are there in Germany?

At the end of September 2026, around 1.53 million plug-in solar devices were registered as operating in the Federal Network Agency's Marktstammdatenregister, with a combined panel capacity of about 1.67 gigawatts. The one-million mark was passed in June 2025.

For me, this number is the belated answer to the 2013 debate. What was dismissed as DIY kits back then now has its own rules in Germany's Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG) and its own product standard. It shows how the energy transition works from the bottom up: people act first, and the rules follow.

What is changing for solar power in the Netherlands?

In the Netherlands, net metering (the salderingsregeling) ends on 1 January 2027. After that, solar power fed into the grid can no longer be offset against your own consumption; until 2030, suppliers must pay a feed-in tariff of at least 50 per cent of the bare supply price excluding taxes.

I live in South Limburg and I can see what this means: from 2027, what counts most in the Netherlands too is the electricity you use yourself. That is exactly what balcony solar is built for.

Why are used solar panels infrastructure and not waste?

A decommissioned solar module has already been manufactured, transported and paid for. If it still produces electricity safely, every module that stays in use replaces a new one. For me, that is the most effective form of circular economy.

Modules are taken down for many reasons: a solar park is repowered with higher-output technology, a roof is renovated, an operator goes bankrupt. Only some of these reasons have anything to do with the condition of the module. The volumes are large. IRENA and the International Energy Agency's Photovoltaic Power Systems Programme (IEA-PVPS) estimate that up to 78 million tonnes (60 to 78 million t depending on the scenario, IRENA/IEA-PVPS 2016) of PV modules worldwide will reach the end of their life by 2050.

Under the WEEE Directive 2012/19/EU, which has applied to photovoltaic modules since 2014, end-of-life modules in the EU count as waste electrical and electronic equipment. That settled how they are taken back. The directive does not answer the question of how many of these modules actually still work.

Refurbishment of used solar modules at Rinovasol
Refurbishing used modules at Rinovasol

How does reCOGNISE, reUSE, reCYCLE work?

reCOGNISE, reUSE, reCYCLE is the process GE4A follows for used solar modules: first test and record them digitally, then put back into service whatever is safe, and only send the rest for material recovery. The order is fixed.

  1. reCOGNISE

    Every module is recorded, tested and graded: type, serial number, output, visible damage, electrical safety. The data is stored digitally and stays linked to the module.

  2. reUSE

    Modules that pass the tests are refurbished and resold as a product, with a test certificate. They go where their remaining output is needed.

  3. reCYCLE

    Modules that cannot responsibly be used again go to licensed processing, where the materials are separated and recovered.

Why do used solar panels need testing before recycling?

Because many decommissioned modules are still good enough for a second life, and some modules that look fine are still not safe. An Australian field study measured both.

Researchers at the Australian National University and CSIRO led by Marco Ernst analysed measurement data from 3,749 decommissioned modules. Based on current-voltage measurement (the I-V curve), 58.1 per cent were still usable under the chosen performance criteria. At the same time, around 14 per cent of the modules that had passed both the I-V measurement and electroluminescence (EL) imaging failed the wet insulation test.

For me, two rules follow from this. Shredding without testing destroys working technology. And reselling without testing puts unsafe modules on roofs. That is why testing always comes first with us, and the insulation test is part of it.

What is recovered when a solar panel is recycled?

The main materials that can be recovered from a crystalline silicon module are glass, aluminium, silicon, silver and copper. According to GE4A's calculations, silver accounts for more than 95 per cent of the recoverable material value.

Glass and the aluminium frame make up most of the weight. The economic value, however, sits in the cells, or more precisely in their silver contacts. A recycling process that only recovers glass and frames leaves the most valuable part behind. Good reCYCLING therefore has to get at the cell.

When is a used solar panel legally waste, and when is it a product?

Under the EU Waste Framework Directive 2008/98/EC, an item is waste if its holder discards it, intends to discard it or is required to discard it. A module that is tested, documented and used again for the same purpose can, on the other hand, remain a product.

The directive distinguishes two routes back into use. Re-use means products that are not waste being used again for the purpose for which they were conceived. Preparing for re-use means checking, cleaning or repairing products that have already become waste so that they can be used again without any other pre-processing. Article 6 also sets out the conditions under which waste ceases to be waste, including that a market exists for it and that it meets the technical requirements.

For cross-border shipments, Annex VI of the WEEE Directive is decisive. Anyone shipping used electrical equipment as a product must be able to show an invoice and contract stating that the goods are intended for direct re-use, a test record for every item, a declaration that the load is not waste, and protective packaging. If any of this is missing, the authorities treat the load as e-waste and the shipment as illegal.

Toralf Nitsch has worked to give the trade in used solar modules in Europe a clear legal framework: separating waste from product, testing and proof. Without that framework there would be no market for second-life solar modules, only a mountain of waste.

What do Toralf Nitsch, GE4A and Rinovasol actually do?

Toralf Nitsch is co-founder and CEO of GE4A Group B.V. in Amsterdam, which now also includes the Rinovasol Group. GE4A processes used modules under licence in Bulgaria, Germany and Spain and has around 40,000 tonnes of annual processing capacity together with network partners.

I helped build Rinovasol to refurbish used modules on an industrial scale. In January 2021 Rinovasol took over production equipment from the insolvency estate of SolarWorld AG for this purpose, and by autumn 2021 the company was active in more than twenty countries.

Own plant
Pazardzhik, Bulgaria
Licensed processing
Bulgaria, Germany, Spain
Capacity
around 40,000 t a year with network partners
Data
CYCLECTRA, an AI-supported platform for module data (being expanded)

Separately, through Logos Consulting I advise companies that want to move into refurbishing, trading or recycling PV modules. More about consulting · How module data goes digital

Frequently asked questions about balcony solar and used solar panels

Can used solar panels be resold?

Yes, used solar modules can be resold if they work and are sold as a product. Testing and proof are what matter. For cross-border shipments, Annex VI of the WEEE Directive requires, among other things, a test record for every module and a declaration that the goods are not waste.

How much silver is in a solar panel?

The silver in a solar module sits in the contacts of its cells. The amount depends on cell type and year of manufacture and is small by weight. Economically it is decisive: according to GE4A's calculations, silver accounts for more than 95 per cent of the recoverable material value of a crystalline module.

Do I have to register a balcony solar system in Germany?

Yes, balcony solar systems in Germany have to be registered in the Federal Network Agency's Marktstammdatenregister, using a simplified form. A separate notification to the grid operator has not been needed since May 2024, as long as the device has no battery.

What is the maximum size for balcony solar in Germany?

In Germany, a balcony solar system may have up to 800 VA of inverter output and 2,000 watts of panel capacity. Several devices on one connection are added together. The product standard DIN VDE V 0126-95 (since December 2025, pre-standard) limits module power to 960 Wp for devices with a Schuko plug.

Who helped start balcony solar in Europe?

Toralf Nitsch is one of the pioneers of balcony solar in Europe. In 2012 he carried out the factory acceptance of Sun Invention's first Plug & Save modules in Wenzhou, China, and in 2013, as technical director and later COO, he brought the product to market despite a warning from Germany's electrical standards body VDE at the time.

Are old solar panels e-waste?

Legally, yes, once they are disposed of: under the WEEE Directive 2012/19/EU, the rules for waste electrical and electronic equipment have applied to photovoltaic modules since 2014. A tested, working module that is used again can, however, remain a product.

How much solar panel waste will there be by 2050?

By 2050, up to 78 million tonnes of PV modules worldwide will reach the end of their life (60 to 78 million t depending on the scenario, IRENA/IEA-PVPS 2016).

Let's talk Enquire about a talk